Having a putter that you can rely on for tee shots and approach shots in all conditions is a very important slot to have. These discs offer the glide of a putter with the consistent fade that you are more used to in approach discs or mid ranges. These are most useful for backhand approaches that need to be shaped and for players that prefer a flat to anhyzer release on their approach shots.
It is important to note the difference between an overstable putter and an approach disc. For this article, we are talking about discs that feel more like your traditional disc golf putter in the hand while still accomplishing that overstable and reliable flight that you are looking for. This flight is easier to find in approach discs which are often grouped in as putters but serve almost as a hybrid between a putter and a mid range. Discs like the Zone, Harp, Toro, Savior, etc. fit into this overstable approach category. If you are looking for a disc that you can throw comfortably both backhand and forehand, the discs I just listed are a better place for you to start.
Below you will find a list of overstable throwing putters that we have tested and love. These are in no particular order but make sure you pay attention to the plastic recommendations under each disc to ensure that you don't get one that ends up being straighter than you want on the course!
The Best Overstable Throwing Putters
Discmania P2x
The P2x really embodies this slot perfectly. It is going to be overstable in most plastics that they manufacture but if you are able to find one in C-Line or Color Glow C-Line that is the best option. This disc has tremendous glide for an overstable putter which makes it a fantastic choice here. Hunter, one of Foundation's personalities, has had one in the bag for almost a year straight and it is still his go to for the overstable putter shots!
DGA Sonar
The Sonar became a staple in DGA's lineup in 2025 and quickly became a go-to for both DGA and Discraft team players. Ezra Robinson actually used them for both throwing and putting when he first joined team Discraft in 2025 and had a lot of success with them. The Sonar is going to start similar to the P2x with a lot of glide and a nice reliable finish. If you want it to keep that level of stability, be sure to pick it up in a premium plastic like their Atmos blend.
Hooligan Cash
The Cash from Hooligan goes under the radar in this slot because it is made by a smaller manufacturer but it might be the most overstable one on this list. The Cash offers players a shallower profile than most putters without sacrificing any stability. This is a great option for people who like to throw putters on anhyzer but still want them to fade at the end of the flight. Trevor Staub is one of the big reasons that this disc has notoriety in this slot and he has relied on it as his main throwing putter for quite some time now!
Dynamic Discs Jury
The Jury is extremely underrated for this slot. It has been called the Judge OS and I think that fits this disc perfectly. The Judge for a long time has been one of the gold standards on the market for straight flying putters and the Jury acts almost as its big brother. If you want an overstable putter that will beat in to flip up reliably, try the Jury in the Classic blend. If you want the overstability to stick around, pick it up in Lucid or Lucid Orbit!
Prodigy Pa-3
Rounding out the list we have the Pa-3 from Prodigy. This one might confuse some people because the higher the number in the prodigy lineup, the more understable the disc is. This is true, but we have found that the premium plastic Pa-3 offers the perfect mix of straight glide with consistent fade on the course. If you pick it up in 300 plastic, expect a much straighter flight. To truly fill that overstable putter slot, be sure to get it in 400 plastic or 400 glow! Even in the premium plastic, still expect this disc to be one of the straighter ones on the list.
Closing Thoughts
No matter which of these discs you choose, filling that overstable throwing putter slot can completely change the way you attack the course. A dependable putter for tee shots and approaches gives you the confidence to commit to your angles, shape creative lines, and trust the disc to finish the way you expect. The key is matching the mold and plastic to your throwing style and the flights you want to see on the course. Once you find the one that clicks, you’ll likely wonder how you ever played without it in your bag.
Frequently Asked Questions About Overstable Throwing Putters
What is an overstable throwing putter?
An overstable throwing putter is a putter designed to resist turning over during flight and finish with a reliable fade. Unlike traditional putters that prioritize straight flights, overstable throwing putters are built for controlled tee shots and approach shots where consistency and wind resistance are important.
What’s the difference between an overstable putter and an approach disc?
The main difference is feel and intended use. Overstable throwing putters feel like traditional putters in the hand and are designed to have more glide. Approach discs are typically faster, flatter, and more overstable, acting like a hybrid between a putter and a midrange. Many players prefer throwing putters for shaping backhand lines and touch approaches.
Who should throw an overstable putter?
Players of all skill levels can benefit from an overstable throwing putter. Beginners gain consistency and predictability on approach shots, while advanced players use them to shape lines, fight wind, and control landing angles near the basket.
What plastic is best for an overstable throwing putter?
Premium plastics are usually best if you want to maintain overstability over time. Baseline plastics tend to beat in faster and fly straighter. Choosing the right plastic depends on whether you want your disc to stay reliably overstable or season into a workable flight.
Can you throw an overstable putter forehand?
Yes, many overstable throwing putters work well for forehand approaches, especially for players who prefer a slower, more controllable disc. However, dedicated approach discs may feel more comfortable for players who rely heavily on forehand shots. Throwing an overstable putter on forehand requires better form and a cleaner release than your typical overstable approach discs.
Are overstable throwing putters good in the wind?
Yes. Their overstability makes them more resistant to turning in headwinds and crosswinds. While no putter is completely windproof, overstable throwing putters are often the most reliable putter option in windy conditions.
Should beginners use overstable putters?
Beginners can benefit from overstable putters for approach shots because they provide predictable fade and reduce the chance of turning over. However, beginners should still practice with neutral putters to develop clean throwing mechanics.